Arrest Leads to Unrest about Pro-life Targeting
April 06, 2020
If there's one thing David Benham isn't social distancing from, it's his convictions. So when police showed up outside a North Carolina abortion clinic that was still operating on Saturday and told his group to stop counseling pregnant moms, he didn't blink. If abortions can continue during the coronavirus, he insisted, then so should pro-life ministry.
Local officials didn't agree. When they asked the Cities4Life volunteers to leave, David refused. "We are a federally recognized 501(c)(3) public charity," he insisted. "We are an essential business." Not only that, he argued, but the group has followed every possible government guidance -- sanitizing and staying at least six-feet apart. That didn't seem to matter. "They've been after us for years," David said later about the leaders in Charlotte. "Against conservative voices. So once this crisis hit, this was their opportunity for a power grab."
In the video that went viral, David can be heard telling the police, "You know I am well within my constitutional authority to be here. You know that we are doing the right thing. If you're saying that we don't have the right to be here, then go in the abortion clinic and make the arrests there." The officer replied, "I don't have the authority to go in the abortion clinic." "So you don't have the authority to go in the abortion clinic," David asked, "but you have the authority to bully us and our sidewalk counselors?" Well, he said firmly, "I'm not budging and my counselors are not budging."
Amazingly, the officers reached for their handcuffs -- arresting David and a handful of others, including his 20-year-old son. He almost started to cry, he admitted later, because he just couldn't believe his country would do this. "And it wasn't the officers," he insisted. "It's whoever's instructing the officers. I can't believe we've gotten to this point where we're going to use a national healthcare emergency... [to] steal constitutional rights from pro-life Christians."
Senator Ted Cruz (R-Texas) couldn't believe it either. He was appalled at the video and on Twitter called it a completely "unconstitutional arrest." David Benham, he exclaimed, was "exercising [his] First Amendment rights. PEACEFULLY. In a way fully consistent with public safety." But, that's what you get when the states election pro-abortion Democrats who decide to use their authority in a "one-sided way to silence pregnancy counselors." Governor Roy Cooper (D), Cruz shook his head, "should be ashamed."
Although David was released that same Saturday, the story is far from over. Attorneys at Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) are more than happy to point out the error of the city's ways -- in court, if necessary. This is viewpoint discrimination, plain and simple. If abortion is "essential," then persuading moms to choose life is too. The coronavirus is deadly, but so is Roe v.Wade. Good for the Benham Brothers for refusing to be intimidated -- not even in the face of bogus charges like Charlotte's. The crisis facing the unborn doesn't take a break when the rest of the world does. Sometimes it takes a stand like this one to remind us.
Tony Perkins's Washington Update is written with the aid of FRC senior writers.