Family Research Council Files Amicus Brief at US Supreme Court in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: July 30, 2021
CONTACT: J.P. Duffy or Joshua Arnold, (866) FRC-NEWS or (866)-372-6397

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Family Research Council filed an amicus brief yesterday with the U.S. Supreme Court in the case of Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, in one of the most significant challenges to the Court's 1973 decision in Roe v. Wade. The Court's decision in Roe held that a woman had a constitutional right to abortion under the Fourteenth Amendment, striking down many state abortion restrictions and severely limiting the extent to which states could write their own abortion laws.

In the brief, we argue: "In Casey, a plurality recognized that Roe and its trimester framework were unworkable and introduced a new 'controlling standard' that was intended to provide judges clarity in deciding abortion cases. But Casey only made things worse. Created 'out of whole cloth,' Casey's undue-burden standard provided no rule of law, instead forcing judges to evaluate abortion regulations on the basis of their own personal value judgments. And its viability rule relied on ever-changing medical technology, while preventing states from acting upon their important interests in protecting nascent life and beyond."

The brief continues: "Instead of aiding judges in 'neutral and principled administration' of the law, the undue burden standard forces [judges] to rely on their own moral intuitions to decide cases. That practice perverts the judicial function and undermines the rule of law."

Family Research Council president Tony Perkins commented on FRC's amicus brief:

"Considering this national trend of legislative action against abortion, the pre-viability restrictions that Mississippi HB 1510 implements are increasingly, and in fact, reflective of the convictions of the nation. America is truly an outlier in extreme abortion laws since most countries around the world limit abortion. It's time that the Courts allow for the states to enact laws that are consistent with the scientific and medical advances in the half century since Roe v. Wade was decided. In 1973, the Court assumed it had settled the debate over abortion. Yet no court can change the truth that a society that does not respect life that is defenseless, does not respect life," concluded Perkins.

Katherine Beck Johnson, FRC's Research Fellow for Legal and Policy Studies, and an attorney who assisted with the brief, added:

"The Court's decisions in Roe and Casey have taken over 60 million lives and done irreparable harm to our country, not just through the lost lives of the aborted babies, but also to their mothers and families. The country is worse off because of the lives lost in abortion. I'm proud that our amicus brief boldly calls for an end to the viability standard that has no grounding in the Constitution. Roe and Casey must be overturned."

To read FRC's amicus brief, please see: https://downloads.frc.org/EF/EF21G39.pdf

To read FRC's state policy brief publication on what states can do to advance life in a post-Roe world, please see: https://www.frc.org/statepolicybrief/total-abortion-ban

More Content On Abortion Laws

Abortion Laws
Family Research Council files comment rebuking HHS's proposed reversal of the abortion surcharge rule
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council Files Amicus Brief at US Supreme Court in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health
Abortion Laws
Born-Alive Abortion Survivors Protection Acts
Abortion Laws
Total Abortion Ban
Abortion Laws
Cease Abortion Subsidies in Healthcare (CASH) Act
Abortion Laws
Don't Mistake China's Three-Child Policy For Liberalization
Abortion Laws
FRC Celebrates Growing Momentum for Protection of the Unborn from Discrimination on the Basis of Race, Sex, or Disability
Abortion Laws
Prenatal Nondiscrimination Acts: Why They Are Essential
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council Urges House Members to Sign Discharge Petition on Born-Alive Abortion Survivors Protection Act
Abortion Laws
Born-Alive Abortion Survivors: Just the Facts
Abortion Laws
When the Patient Becomes the Physician
Abortion Laws
FRC urges US Senate to Reject Radical HHS Nominee Xavier Becerra
Abortion Laws
FRC urges US House of Representatives to reject the far-Left Equality Act
Abortion Laws
So-Called 'Equality Act' Harms Women, Punishes People of Faith, and Creates an Abortion Mandate says Family Research Council
Abortion Laws
FRC's Mary Szoch Submits Testimony on Connecticut Bill Targeting Pro-Life Pregnancy Centers
Abortion Laws
Roe Must End: The Legal, Historical, and Cultural Reasons to Overturn Roe v. Wade
Abortion Laws
The Holding of Roe v. Wade Was Never In Line with American Attitudes on Abortion
Abortion Laws
Roe v. Wade: An Explainer
Abortion Laws
Biden's HHS nomination sign of admin's likely extreme abortion course
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council Defends the Hyde Amendment as House Democrats Try to Eliminate It
Abortion Laws
FRC's New Pro-Life Map Shows Which States Fund Planned Parenthood and Other Abortion Centers
Abortion Laws
FRC laments defeat for women's health in Supreme Court's abortionist admitting privileges decision
Abortion Laws
Here's How the Abortion Industry Should Be Remembered for Handling the Pandemic
Abortion Laws
U.S. Senate's Rejection of Born-Alive Bill, Pain-Capable Bill Shows How Extreme Congressional Democrats Have Become
Abortion Laws
Why We Need the Born-Alive Abortion Survivors Protection Act
Abortion Laws
FRC's Katherine Johnson to Speak at Virginia March for Life
Abortion Laws
FRC's Patrina Mosley Testifies Before Senate Judiciary Committee on the 'Born Alive Abortion Survivors Protection Act'
Abortion Laws
FRC's Patrina Mosley to Speak at National Pro-Life Summit 2020
Abortion Laws
Marching for Lives
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council to Host ProLifeCon 2020
Abortion Laws
FRC Releases New Map Showing Which States Protect the Human Dignity of Unborn Children
Abortion Laws
47th anniversary of Roe v. Wade: Increasing opposition to abortion nationwide
Abortion Laws
FRC Responds to Planned Parenthood's Annual Report
Abortion Laws
FRC, CLI find: All Obamacare Health Insurance Plans in 8 States and DC Cover Abortion on Demand for 2020
Abortion Laws
The Next Abortion Battleground: Chemical Abortion
Abortion Laws
Fetal Dignity Laws: Respecting the Human Dignity of the Unborn
Abortion Laws
FRC Opposes Putting Abortion Pills on College Campuses
Abortion Laws
New Family Research Council Map Shows Which States Have Strong Born-Alive Protections
Abortion Laws
The Human Dignity of Klopfer's Victims
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council Applauds House Minority for Holding Hearing on Born Alive Abortion Survivors
Abortion Laws
Unplanned movie also reveals the violence of the abortion pill
Abortion Laws
Abortion Industry Profits Trample Women's Interests in Sacramento
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council's Patrina Mosley speaks at National Day of Mourning event in Richmond, VA
Abortion Laws
FRC Applauds Enforcement of New Title X Rule Separating Taxpayer Dollars from Abortion Industry
Abortion Laws
Will California Turn Dorm Rooms into Abortion Rooms?
Abortion Laws
Title X Rule Changes Protect the Unborn and Increase Health Care Options
Abortion Laws
Is the Republican Senate Ready to Advance Pro-Life Policy?
Abortion Laws
UPDATE: 12th Annual ProLifeCon Digital Action Summit at Family Research Council
Abortion Laws
12th Annual ProLifeCon Digital Action Summit at Family Research Council
Abortion Laws
7 Years on, Obamacare Is Less Pro-Life Than Anything We Were Told
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council Praises House Passage of Conscience Protection Act
Abortion Laws
Q&A on the Abortion Facility Regulations Decision
Abortion Laws
Supreme Court Decision on Whole Woman's Health v. Hellerstedt Devalues Women's Safety
Abortion Laws
Rep. Diane Black to Speak at Family Research Council on the House Select Investigative Panel on Infant Lives
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council Calls for Investigation of Illegal Federal Funding of Abortion at Health Centers
Abortion Laws
FRC Asks Supreme Court to Make Abortion Centers Accountable to Health and Safety Standards
Abortion Laws
Family Research Council Releases Issue Analysis of Planned Parenthood and Biotech Industry Use of Aborted Babies
Abortion Laws
11th Annual ProLifeCon to Feature Majority Whip Scalise, Sen. Ernst, Governor Brownback, David Daleiden
Abortion Laws
What Science Reveals about Fetal Pain
Abortion Laws
Abortion Funding and Obamacare

About Family Research Council

For over 35 years, we've been committed to advancing faith, family, and freedom in public policy and the culture from a biblical worldview.

Learn more